How to communicate effectively with candidates during recruitment. Practical tips, rejection templates, and rules that work. Transparency builds trust
🎯 Key Message
Transparency is more important than speed. Candidates will forgive delays, but they won't forgive silence. Always communicate – even when you have nothing new to say.
Imagine you're waiting for important medical test results. The doctor said they'd call by Friday. It's Monday, the phone is silent. What do you think? That's exactly how candidates feel when you promise feedback and then go silent.
According to our Candidate Experience test data, inadequate communication is the most common cause of negative recruitment process ratings. And paradoxically, it's one of the easiest things to improve – it doesn't cost a cent extra.
Why Transparency Matters More Than Speed
Many recruiters focus on speed: "I must respond within 24 hours." While commendable, if you don't have specific information, a quick response like "Still waiting" without context isn't much better than silence.
Transparency means:
Telling the truth about what's happening, even when that truth isn't ideal. Candidates appreciate honesty: "The hiring manager is on vacation this week, we'll have results by next Wednesday" is much better than vague "We'll be in touch".
💡 Rule #1
If you said you'd call – call. Even if you don't have results. Even if you have nothing new to say. Just call and say you don't have information yet, but you haven't forgotten.
5 Situations Where Recruiters Typically Go Silent (And Shouldn't)
The following scenarios are from real practice. For each, I show how not to handle it and how to handle it correctly.
You promised the candidate you'd get back to them Friday with interview results. It's Friday afternoon and the manager still hasn't responded to your email.
❌ Wrong
Don't reach out. Wait for the manager and hope the candidate waits too. On Monday, write: "Sorry for the delay, still waiting for a decision."
✓ Right
Call or write Friday afternoon:
"Hi [name], as promised, I'm reaching out. Unfortunately, I don't have final feedback from the hiring manager yet – they had a demanding project this week and couldn't complete it. We definitely haven't forgotten about you. I'll follow up again on Tuesday, by which time I'll certainly have a concrete answer. Have a great weekend."
After the second interview round, leadership decided they want a third round with the CEO. The candidate was expecting a final decision.
❌ Wrong
Write: "We'd like to invite you to another interview round." Without explaining why the process extended.
✓ Right
"[Name], I have news – your candidacy impressed us so much that our CEO, [name], would like to meet you personally. I know this extends the process, and I apologize for that. I want to be transparent: we didn't originally plan this round, but [CEO name] made time to meet final candidates personally. Could you manage next week? I'm offering you these options: [times]."
The candidate passed two rounds and is waiting for an offer. Meanwhile, a hiring freeze was announced.
❌ Wrong
Silence. Or after weeks: "Unfortunately, we decided to go with another candidate."
✓ Right
"[Name], I unfortunately have to share some bad news. Due to an internal decision, we had to pause hiring for this position. I want to be honest: this decision has nothing to do with your candidacy – on the contrary, you were in our final selection and the team's feedback was very positive. Once the situation changes, I'd be happy to reach out. If you're interested, we can stay connected on LinkedIn. I'm very sorry for the complications."
You have two great finalists. You're negotiating an offer with the first one, the second is waiting.
❌ Wrong
Leave the second candidate waiting a week in uncertainty until the first one signs.
✓ Right
"[Name], I want to update you on the selection process status. We have two excellent final candidates and you are one of them. We're currently finalizing the decision with leadership. I expect to have a definitive answer by [specific date]. I know waiting is difficult, and I appreciate your patience. Is there anything you need to know or that I can answer in the meantime?"
The candidate emails asking about status. You still don't have feedback from the manager.
❌ Wrong
Wait until you have a concrete answer. Or respond after 3 days.
✓ Right
Respond within 24 hours, ideally sooner:
"Thank you for the follow-up! I apologize for not reaching out first. I'm currently waiting for feedback from [hiring manager / leadership / team], which I should have by [date]. As soon as I have concrete information, I'll contact you immediately. Thank you for your patience."
⚠️ Golden Rule
Never say "we'll be in touch" without providing a specific date. "We'll be in touch next week" is better than "we'll be in touch soon." "We'll be in touch by Wednesday at 3 PM" is best.
When and How Often to Communicate
Communication frequency depends on the process stage. Here's the recommended timeline:
Immediately
Application confirmation – if you have an ATS, this should be sent automatically right after submission. The candidate must know their CV arrived.
Within 1–2 business days
Phone contact with relevant candidates. For high-volume positions (e.g., operators, warehouse workers), an alternative can be a prescreening email with a short questionnaire or task.
Within 5 business days
First decision – invitation to interview, or rejection. No response = silent rejection = brand damage.
Within 48 hours after interview
Thank you and information about next steps. The candidate just made time and prepared – they deserve a quick response.
Within 5 business days after interview
Result – advancement to next round, or rejection with specific reason.
Every week
Update if process takes longer than announced. Even a short message "still waiting for feedback, I'll reach out Friday" is better than silence.
Rejection Templates That Won't Destroy Your Reputation
Rejection is the moment of truth. How you reject a candidate defines your employer brand more than anything else. Every rejected candidate is a potential future employee, customer, or someone who will talk about you.
The following templates are designed to be:
✓ Personalized – include specific name and position reference
✓ Specific – state a legitimate reason (not vague phrases)
✓ Legally safe – contain no discriminatory reasons
✓ Human – preserve the candidate's dignity
🚫 Reasons You Should NEVER State
Age, gender, marital status, pregnancy, health condition, ethnic origin, religion, political beliefs. These reasons are discriminatory and illegal. If the real reason is any of the above, you have a problem – and not just a communication one.
Rejection After CV Review (Before Interview)
Reason: Missing relevant experience
Dear [name],
Thank you for your interest in the [position title] position at [company name].
After careful review of your profile, we've decided not to proceed with your candidacy. For this position, we're looking for candidates with direct experience in [specific area, e.g., "B2B sales in the IT sector"], which we didn't find in your resume at this time.
Your experience in [area where candidate has strengths] is undoubtedly valuable, and I believe you'll find a position where you can fully utilize it.
Best of luck in your continued search.
Best regards,
[your name]
💡 Tip: If the candidate has potential for another position, add: "If a position opens in [X] area, I'd be happy to reach out."
Reason: Missing certification / education / license
Dear [name],
Thank you for your interest in the [position title] position.
Unfortunately, I must inform you that your candidacy cannot proceed at this time. This role requires [specific requirement, e.g., "Class C driver's license", "PRINCE2 certification", "completed technical university degree"], which is required by [reason, e.g., "the nature of the work", "our clients", "regulatory requirements"].
If you obtain this license/certification in the future and are still interested, please don't hesitate to reach out.
Best regards,
[your name]
Rejection After First Interview
Reason: Insufficient technical knowledge
Dear [name],
Thank you again for your time during the interview for the [position title] position. It was a pleasure meeting you and learning more about your experience.
After careful consideration, we've decided not to proceed with your candidacy. During the interview, we found that your current knowledge level in [specific area, e.g., "database work", "financial modeling in Excel", "network infrastructure configuration"] doesn't yet reach the level we need for this position.
I appreciated your [specific positive, e.g., "openness and eagerness to learn new things", "structured approach to problem-solving"]. If you continue developing in this area, you'll certainly have a chance to succeed in similar roles.
Best of luck.
Best regards,
[your name]
Reason: Candidate's expectations don't match position
Dear [name],
Thank you for our conversation about the [position title] position.
After our meeting, I've concluded that this role probably isn't the right step for your career. From our conversation, I understood that you're looking for a position with more focus on [what candidate is looking for, e.g., "strategic planning", "working with people", "technical development"], while this position is primarily about [what the position offers].
I don't want to offer you a role where you'd feel frustrated within six months. I believe you'll find a position that better matches your ambitions.
Best of luck.
Best regards,
[your name]
💡 Tip: Use this reason when you sense the candidate would leave the position soon or wouldn't be satisfied.
Reason: Financial requirements exceed capabilities
Dear [name],
Thank you for the open conversation about the [position title] position.
After our meeting, I consulted your expectations with leadership. Unfortunately, I must be honest: your financial expectations significantly exceed the budget we have approved for this position, and we don't have the ability to increase the offer in this regard.
Your experience and competencies are undoubtedly at a level that matches your requirements – it's just that our current capabilities don't align with them.
If our situation changes or a more senior position with appropriate compensation opens up, I'd be happy to reach out.
Best regards,
[your name]
Rejection After Final Round
Reason: Another candidate was a better fit
Dear [name],
First, I want to thank you for the time and energy you devoted to our selection process for the [position title] position. I truly appreciate it.
I unfortunately must inform you that after long deliberation, we decided to offer the position to another candidate. It wasn't an easy decision – your [specific strengths, e.g., "team leadership experience", "analytical skills", "market knowledge"] impressed us.
In the final decision, the other candidate's specific experience in [specific area, e.g., "CRM system implementation", "working with enterprise clients", "product scaling"] prevailed, which is crucial for the current project phase.
I'd like to stay in touch. If a similar position opens up, I'd be happy to reach out.
Thank you again and best of luck.
Best regards,
[your name]
Reason: Mismatch with company culture
Dear [name],
Thank you for your time throughout the entire selection process for the [position title] position.
After careful consideration of all aspects, we've decided not to proceed with your candidacy. Your professional knowledge is unquestionable. However, during our conversations, we identified different expectations regarding [specific aspect, e.g., "level of decision-making autonomy", "team collaboration style", "pace of implementing changes", "work-life balance"].
This isn't criticism – it's simply a different work style. You would likely excel more in a different environment than with us, and we wouldn't be able to provide what you're looking for.
I wish you find a team that matches your expectations.
Best regards,
[your name]
💡 Note: "Cultural fit" must not be a cover for discrimination. Always state a specific work aspect (communication style, pace, autonomy), not personality traits.
Special Situations
Situation: Candidate chose competitor
Dear [name],
I understand your decision and thank you for letting us know. I'm sorry it didn't work out this time, but I respect your choice.
If your situation changes in the future or you're considering a change, please don't hesitate to reach out. The door is open.
Best of luck in your new role!
Best regards,
[your name]
Situation: Rejecting a colleague
Dear [name],
Thank you for expressing interest in the [position title] position. I appreciate that you want to grow within [company name].
After considering all candidacies, we decided to fill the position differently. The main reason was [specific reason, e.g., "that we needed experience managing a larger team for this role", "specific technical knowledge in area X"].
I'd like to meet with you and discuss your further development. I see potential in [specific area] and would be happy to discuss options for how to reach similar positions in the future.
Let me know when would work for you?
Best regards,
[your name]
💡 Important: Internal candidates need a personal approach. Offer a follow-up meeting to discuss their development.
Reason: Position is below candidate's level
Dear [name],
Thank you for meeting about the [position title] position.
I'll be honest: your experience and competencies significantly exceed what this role offers. I'm concerned that you would feel underutilized and frustrated within a few months, which wouldn't be fair to you or to us.
We're looking for a candidate for whom this position would be a career step forward – and for you, it would be a step back or sideways.
If a more senior role matching your experience opens up, I'll definitely reach out.
Best regards,
[your name]
Checklist: Before Sending Any Message
✅ Communication Checklist
✓
Is the message personalized? (name, position, specific detail)
✓
Do I state a specific date for next contact?
✓
Is the rejection reason legitimate and non-discriminatory?
✓
Do I mention at least one positive thing about the candidate?
✓
Is the message concise? (nobody reads novels)
✓
Would I send this message to my friend?
✓
Is the message free of typos and grammar errors?
Conclusion: Communication Is an Investment, Not a Cost
Every email, every phone call, every text is an investment in your employer brand. A rejected candidate today could be your best employee in two years. Or a friend of someone you desperately need to hire.
Transparency builds trust. And trust is a currency that's hard to earn in the recruiting world, but easy to lose.
Remember: It's not bad to not have an answer. What's bad is not saying you don't have one.
📊 How Is Your Candidate Communication?
Discover your weak spots in the recruitment process with our free test.
Take the Free Test →